Wednesday, September 13, 2006
Different strokes for different folks
George Packer, writing in the New Yorker, illuminates the differences between Our Dear Embattled Leader who is seeking to legitimize his penchant for torturing those he can control and the US military which has to operate in the real world. Using ODEL's speech last week and the unveiling of the Army's new field manual on "human intelligence collector operations" he points out the surreal nature of ODEL and Planet Bushovik.
And when a reporter asked whether some of the now forbidden forms of torture might have been useful in gaining information, General Kimmons directly contradicted what his Commander-in-Chief was saying at the White House:Those wacky Republicans never really did like the military. Perhaps that is why so few have served honorably.
No good intelligence is going to come from abusive practices. I think history tells us that. I think the empirical evidence of the last five years, hard years, tells us that. And, moreover, any piece of intelligence which is obtained under duress, through the use of abusive techniques, would be of questionable credibility, and additionally it would do more harm than good when it inevitably became known that abusive practices were used. And we can’t afford to go there. Some of our most significant successes on the battlefield have been—in fact, I would say all of them, almost categorically all of them, have accrued from expert interrogators using mixtures of authorized humane interrogation practices, in clever ways that you would hope Americans would use them, to push the envelope within the bookends of legal, moral, and ethical, now as further refined by this field manual. So we don’t need abusive practices in there.
Last week, in the guise of calling for fair trials, the President demanded that Congress give him the power to go on torturing detainees in secret prisons and use the evidence obtained against them. And last week the Army honorably closed the holes in moral conduct that the President, his counsel, the Vice-President, the Justice Department, and the Secretary of Defense pried open shortly after September 11th. It did so not only to remove the stain on its reputation and to protect its soldiers but because it cares more about the war than about the next election.
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]
Post a Comment